Short answer: These four ingredients work on pain in different ways, and the studies cover different kinds of pain, so there isn’t one clear winner. Diclofenac’s label is for arthritis pain. Capsaicin is conditionally recommended for knee osteoarthritis by the American College of Rheumatology, and it has specific study data for nerve pain after shingles. Menthol, camphor and lidocaine have thinner research for the joint and muscle pain most people search about. We’d suggest you start by naming your pain type (joint, muscle or nerve), then use the tables below to match it to an ingredient.
How each ingredient works
Each one acts on a different part of the pain system, which is why their labels and studies differ.
- Menthol activates TRPM8, the receptor that senses cold and produces the cooling feeling. A review of topical treatments for musculoskeletal pain says menthol may desensitize nerve fibers, similar to capsaicin, and that TRPM8 activation reduces blood flow to the extremities, much like icing.
- Camphor activates TRPV3, which desensitizes sensory nerves. It can also activate TRPV1, like capsaicin, but the same review says it is not as effective.
- Capsaicin stimulates the TRPV1 receptor and depletes substance P, a chemical involved in pain signals, from sensory nerves, according to a Pharmacy Today article on topical pain relievers (April 2023).
- Lidocaine is a local anesthetic, as described in a Cochrane review of topical lidocaine for neuropathic pain. The Arthritis-Health.com consumer guide describes it as numbing and “muting” pain signals.
- Diclofenac is a topical NSAID. Pharmacy Today says that, like oral NSAIDs, it decreases prostaglandin production to reduce pain and inflammation, but it is applied directly to the area.
What each label says, and how fast it works
The FDA requires OTC medicine labels to list information in the same order, so the Drug Facts panel is where you check each product’s uses and warnings. The FDA guide to the Drug Facts label explains each section.
| Ingredient | Class and how it works | What the label or source says it is for | Key warning |
|---|---|---|---|
| Diclofenac (1% gel) | Topical NSAID; reduces prostaglandins | Arthritis pain reliever, only on the hand, wrist, elbow, foot, ankle or knee | Severe allergic reaction, especially with aspirin allergy; liver damage if used more or longer than directed; severe stomach bleeding |
| Capsaicin (0.1%) | TRPV1 receptor; depletes substance P | Temporarily relieves minor pain of muscles and joints with arthritis, simple backache, strains, sprains and bruises | Rare serious burns; do not use with other topical analgesics; stop if severe burning occurs |
| Lidocaine | Local anesthetic; numbs nerve signals | Local anesthetic used on the skin for neuropathic pain, per the 2014 Cochrane review; OTC use wording is on each product’s Drug Facts panel | Per a consumer arthritis guide: overuse can cause serious effects such as irregular heartbeat; not to be used with heat packs or cold compresses |
| Menthol | Counterirritant; TRPM8 cooling | Counterirritant; Pharmacy Today lists menthol products at 1% to 16% | See the shared warnings below |
| Camphor | Counterirritant; TRPV3 activation | Counterirritant; Pharmacy Today lists camphor products at 3.1% to 11% | See the shared warnings below |
How fast each one works
The diclofenac 1% gel label says it may take up to 7 days to work for arthritis pain and is not for immediate relief. It says to stop if there is no pain relief in 7 days.
For capsaicin, the capsaicin 0.1% label says to repeat as necessary, no more than 3 to 4 times daily, and that a transient burning sensation may occur but generally disappears in several days. The same label says to stop and ask a doctor if symptoms persist for more than 7 days. Pharmacy Today gives a separate onset figure: capsaicin’s effect lasts only 4 to 6 hours and may take up to two weeks to work, which is why it is used several times a day.
If you want more on capsaicin’s human studies and safety, see Cayenne and Capsaicin Benefits: Human Evidence and Safety (our research library).
If your feet are what bother you, our guide to urea cream for feet covers a different kind of topical. If you’re also comparing supplements for exercise recovery, see our look at cordyceps for athletic performance.
Which ingredient fits your pain type
The research sorts more clearly by pain type than by ingredient.
| Ingredient | Arthritis and joint pain | Muscle, strain and back pain | Nerve pain |
|---|---|---|---|
| Diclofenac | Effective for osteoarthritis pain in a 2017 Cochrane review, as Pharmacy Today summarizes it | Label covers arthritis pain only | Pharmacy Today says the same 2017 review found no evidence of support for other chronic pain conditions |
| Capsaicin | Conditionally recommended for knee osteoarthritis by the American College of Rheumatology; SORT level B in the musculoskeletal review | Label lists strains, sprains, bruises and simple backache | High-concentration capsaicin: moderate-quality evidence of limited efficacy in postherpetic neuralgia |
| Lidocaine | A consumer arthritis guide calls it an effective anesthetic for arthritis pain; that is the guide’s description, not a study result | Same consumer guide, for musculoskeletal pain | Rated very low quality in the Cochrane overview of topical analgesics |
| Menthol | Less research than capsaicin; SORT level C in the musculoskeletal review | SORT level C for pain from musculoskeletal injuries | No nerve-pain data in the musculoskeletal review |
Which is better for arthritis pain, lidocaine or menthol?
Neither has a clear edge here, so your pain type and how you feel about each warning should guide the choice. Lidocaine’s arthritis wording comes from the Arthritis-Health.com consumer guide, which calls it an effective anesthetic for arthritis and musculoskeletal pain. The Cochrane overview of topical analgesics rates the lidocaine evidence as very low quality. For menthol, the musculoskeletal review gives a SORT level C and says it can be offered for pain from musculoskeletal injuries, with less data behind it than capsaicin.
Is capsaicin better than diclofenac?
They suit different pain, so neither is simply better. The musculoskeletal review notes that NSAIDs are generally favored by NICE and the American College of Rheumatology, while capsaicin is conditionally recommended for knee osteoarthritis. The review says its use should be guided by patient preference, costs and individual response. For diclofenac, the 2017 Cochrane review by Derry and colleagues found it effective for osteoarthritis pain, as Pharmacy Today summarizes it. In the broader Cochrane overview, fewer people stopped topical diclofenac because it wasn’t working than stopped placebo: 6% versus 9%, across 11 studies with 3,455 participants. Pharmacy Today’s reading is that the research shows only modest benefits.
Capsaicin vs lidocaine for nerve pain and shingles
Postherpetic neuralgia is nerve pain that can follow shingles, and the NHS shingles page covers it. In the Cochrane overview, high-concentration capsaicin had moderate-quality evidence of limited efficacy in postherpetic neuralgia: 33% on capsaicin versus 24% on placebo, across 2 studies and 571 participants. The number needed to treat was 11, with a range of 6.1 to 62, meaning about 11 people need the product for one extra person to get a benefit over placebo. The same overview rated the evidence for low-concentration capsaicin and lidocaine as very low quality. You can read the Cochrane review of high-concentration capsaicin directly, and the prescription 8% capsaicin label lists that higher-strength product’s own warnings.
Capsaicin vs lidocaine for back pain
The capsaicin 0.1% label lists simple backache among its uses. The Arthritis-Health.com consumer guide says capsaicin can be effective on deeper areas such as the back, hips and shoulders. For lidocaine, the only back-related wording is that guide’s general line about musculoskeletal pain.
Lidocaine vs menthol vs camphor
The musculoskeletal review gives menthol a SORT level C and says it can be offered for pain from musculoskeletal injuries. It gives camphor a SORT level C too, and says camphor may not be a reasonable or effective alternative for musculoskeletal pain and that studies proving its effect are lacking. Lidocaine’s arthritis wording comes from the consumer guide noted above, and the Cochrane overview rates its evidence as very low quality.
Is diclofenac just ibuprofen, and is there a better anti-inflammatory?
Diclofenac is an NSAID, and so are the topical ibuprofen gels and creams the Cochrane overview covers alongside it. That overview called the evidence limited for ibuprofen gels and creams and for some diclofenac formulations, including unspecified formulations and diclofenac gel other than Emulgel. It found moderate-quality evidence for diclofenac Emulgel and diclofenac plasters in acute strains and sprains, and it stressed that the exact formulation matters. Pharmacy Today notes that when diclofenac is applied as the prescription package insert directs, the amount absorbed into the body is 17 times lower than the systemic exposure from oral diclofenac. The research here doesn’t name a better anti-inflammatory or rank any of these as the strongest. Capsaicin and menthol work through different nerve pathways, not the prostaglandin pathway, so they are different tools rather than stronger versions of diclofenac.
Natural options: what “natural” does and doesn’t tell you
Menthol, camphor and capsaicin come from plants, which is why they’re often called natural options. That word doesn’t tell you how well a product works or how safe it is, so read the warnings below for each one. Diclofenac works through the prostaglandin pathway, a different route from the plant-derived options.
Safety: warnings to know
- Pharmacy Today says topical pain relievers should not be used on broken or irritated skin, or with a heating pad or bandage, and should be kept away from the eyes, nose and mouth. The capsaicin label adds not to bandage the area tightly, apply local heat, or apply a medicated patch to it.
- The Arthritis-Health.com consumer guide says lidocaine should not be used with heat packs or cold compresses.
- The diclofenac label warns of a severe allergic reaction, especially in people allergic to aspirin, and says liver damage may occur if it is applied more or for longer than directed.
- The capsaicin label says to keep the product out of reach of children, that children 18 or younger should ask a doctor, and that if anything is swallowed you should get medical help or contact a Poison Control Center right away.
- If you are pregnant or breastfeeding, the capsaicin label says to ask a health professional before use.
- Pharmacy Today says people sensitive to salicylates, or those taking blood thinners, should use salicylate products or diclofenac with caution.
When to check with a clinician first
Pharmacy Today advises that if an OTC topical pain reliever doesn’t relieve your pain, you should consult your pharmacist or physician about other options, including prescription topical NSAIDs or lidocaine. The diclofenac label says to stop use and seek medical help right away if you have an allergic reaction, such as hives, asthma (wheezing), skin reddening, blisters, facial swelling, shock or rash. The capsaicin label also says to stop and ask a doctor if symptoms persist for more than 7 days or clear up and occur again within a few days, or if you notice redness, irritation, or pain, swelling or blistering where you applied it.
Checklists
What to compare
- Your pain type: joint, muscle or nerve.
- The uses and warnings on each Drug Facts panel.
- How long each one takes: the diclofenac label says up to 7 days, and the capsaicin label says to ask a doctor if symptoms persist for more than 7 days. Pharmacy Today’s separate onset figure for capsaicin is up to two weeks.
What to track
- The date you started, and how many times a day you apply it.
- Any burning, redness or skin changes after each use.
What to bring
- A list of every medicine you take, especially blood thinners and any aspirin products.
- The package, so the pharmacist can read the Drug Facts panel with you.
What to ask a pharmacist
- Which of these fits my pain type, and does it interact with my other medicines?
- What should I do if there is no relief after the time on the label?
By the Integrative Health Evidence Guide Team
This article is for general information purposes only and does not constitute medical advice. Consult your doctor or qualified healthcare provider before making changes to your health routine.